Well as we know the Sharks got thumped on Saturday. I think there were very few people in this country that over-reacted to the loss… unless you are a staunch Sharks supporter. The fact that the chiefs won is more down to the fact that they were the fresher team than the better team. In fact, if the Sharks were given an extra week I have no doubts that the title would have been theirs.
The first few minutes the Sharks were in the game, but then one could see the engine start to sputter as the tank was getting empty. The outcome was almost inevitable, but there were a few (including myself) who thought they might pull off another Newlands.
Later in the day the Springbok squad was announced. Once again it wasn’t all that unexpected, but it did make me angry unlike the Sharks loss. The Sharks had an excuse, they were mentally and physically at their limit. Heyneke has no excuse for sticking with a Bok fake in the form of Morné Steyn. He is the biggest eye-sore in the squad, the word that makes me cringe, almost like a kick in the gonads. He was only ever adequate as a player, but now his adequacy has left him (kicking). Heyneke states he will coach him back to his “brilliant best”. The thing is he was never brilliant or the best, just adequate. What does that say about the younger generation coming through, the guys with truck loads more talent than Morné? Sorry you’re not a Bull so bugger off? Sounds like it. Meyer managed to turn the fortunes of two players in theEnglandtour, namely Habana and Olivier, in the space of a few games. Morné by contrast has only got worse. So no, I don’t think Meyer will succeed in sorting Morné out. He is more interested in his pink boots.
The other lucky Boks in my opinion are Jacques Potgieter, Jean de Villiers (I know we need a captain but his rugby has been bad the last while), Pierre Spies, Jano Vermaak, Flip van der Merwe and Zane Kirchner. I know Jacques is a hustle and bustle type player. He has no regard for his body and gives his all. But if you want to play him you will have to drop someone like Marcell Coetzee because you need a hard running flank that can get over the advantage line while damaging the defender, ala Willem Alberts, because we all know (and the Bulls supporters too) that Spies will never and can never do that. Jano Vermaak is lucky. He hasn’t played rugby all season but still gets picked above someone like McLeod, our best scrumhalf of the Super 15. That just proves that form means squat and being a Bull means everything. Books can be written about the useful impact players like Pierre Spies, Zane Kirchner and Flip van der Merwe make on a rugby field. It will be a one sentence book and if you combine the three it will be a three sentence book.
Jean de Villiers… one of my current heroes. This season he has been indifferent. If you would like to point fingers at a backline that fails to get away then I feel it should be aimed at this man. He was once a magician in the midfield and with Jaque Fourie at his side they were one of the best combinations ever. Jean will have to pull up his socks and improve on his game. His vision seems to have diminished, his once great distribution game is fast becoming myth. At least he still has more to offer than Morné.
The only true vision Heyneke has produced in the naming of this squad was getting Pat Cilliers in at the expense of Werner Kruger and finally picking Kolisi, who actually earned his position and wasn’t gifted it for wearing a baby blue or pink jumper this season. But the issue of picking Pat raises another. If Werner Kruger was dropped because of poor form (and being useless), then why wasn’t Morné offered the same deal? Why did Werner have to fall on the sword instead of getting coached better?
Springbok squad
Forwards: Willem Alberts, Andries Bekker, Pat Cilliers, Marcell Coetzee, Keegan Daniel, Bismarck du Plessis, Jannie du Plessis, Eben Etzebeth, Dean Greyling, Siya Kolisi, Juandre Kruger, Tendai Mtawarira, Jacques Potgieter, Chiliboy Ralepelle, Pierre Spies, Adriaan Strauss, Flip van der Merwe.
Backs: Jean de Villiers (c), JJ Engelbrecht, Bryan Habana, Francois Hougaard, Elton Jantjies, Zane Kirchner, Patrick Lambie, Lwazi Mvovo, Ruan Pienaar, JP Pietersen, Frans Steyn, Morné Steyn, Jano Vermaak.

I share your sentiments in disappointment with this squad. I differ with you on Jean though, he was brilliant in the 3 tests against England. The core of the problem at the Stormers isn’t him, its the entire plan and then the failure of Duvenhange and Grant to create space for the backs by playing to a defensive pattern.
The selections shows a complete lack of vision going forward and I agree with your view that, unless you wear the Blue and Pink, you need to be very special to get into the Bok squad.
What has De Jongh and Aplon done wrong (except their last match vs the Sharks) to be desserted as if they never were good enough, and be replaced by rookies like JJ and Kirchner?
What has Piet van Zyl done wrong all season to be outranked by someone who hardly played any rugby, and if he did he was kak?
Are Goosen, Oostuizen and Vermeulen injuries the reason for not being selected?
If Kanko going to Japan is reason for his exclusion, why is Pienaar included, playing for Ulster?
Dunno, but I’m disappointed with Meyer’s selections and attitude right now and it leaves a very bad taste in my mouth.
Nail on the head! I know Oosthuizen is a definite no and Goosen still has a few weeks left on his shoulder. Duane should be back real soon… like this weekend. So who knows? Hopefully it is bye bye Spies after the Argentina game. Now if we could only get rid of Morné I’d be very happy.
Actually, the “Rugby Chapionship” falls outside of the IRB test window. Therefore the clubs don’t have to release their players.
Ruan has a clause in his contract allowing him to represent the Springboks at any time. The Japan-bound players (SBW, Meisiekind and Kanko) don’t.
Argentina found a way around this by negotiating with the clubs that their players would not play in the June tests, but would then be available for the Rugby Championship.
Ok, so that’s why Ruan can play and Kanko not…but then, if Meyer did want Kanko as he said he did, why didn’t he get the same clause into Kanko’s contract?
I think its just BS, that he wanted him but that his move to Japan made it impossible.
I dont think Kanko himself thought he would be this much of a Bok favourite when he signed his deal.
The main reason is probably that the Japanese club made him a offer for the 6 months, with a price tag. Looking at Jacques Fourie, that normally equates to about 3 times what he would earn locally (WITH a Bok Contract (which i dont thnk he has))
Kanko really has hit amazing form the last while.
I have it on pretty good authority that HM’s plan was to start Duane at 8, and then play Pierre in a Bobby Skinstadt circa 1997 impact role with 20 min to go. He does ahve the skill set and the pace for that kind of job.
I’m more interested in who is not going to make the team should Juan and Schalk come back and return to form. They might pull a Andre Venter and have Juan return to 4 lock.
I totally agree Uysh.
1st, to the Sharks. I will not use travel as an excuse for our loss. Its a professional era and by now you should know that travel is part of it. If you wanted a better deal we should have won more games..plain and simple.
2nd, ya, the least said about Morne the better. I know he got married and that his dad recently had some issues with the law. Maybe hat all plays a role. We can only speculate.
Finishing 6th on the log was always going to make it a tough ask for the Sharks and they did well to reach the final but crossing the Indian Ocean three time in as many weeks was just too much.
Pingback: Jaque : The Latest Fuzz