Dunedin a wakeup call for England against Black Caps

Whilst the Ausies is going down heavily in India, England’s hopes for a whitewash in the land of the Black Caps were dashed by a resolute and revived Kiwi-team.

After their South African ordeal the Kiwis came hard at England and only a rained out first day rescued England from serious embarrassment. That; and the defiant knock of Steven Finn (56 from 203 balls and almost five hours) as night watchman in England’s second innings, saved the visitors.

The Kiwis at least scored the moral victory which could result in sufficient confidence and a subsequent victory in one of the remaining tests. Dunedin showed the route to beat the English and after the first test the belief will be there.

The outcome of the first test will bother the English who thought it was good enough just to pitch up. A similar attitude prevailed before the South Africans arrived in England last year and the hosts lost that series with two to none.

In Dunedin it did not work out like the English suspected and to add insult to injury the drawn test widened the gap between them and the Proteas. The draw cost England a potential point on Reliance’s ICC Test Championship Table Predictor. Even if England wins the next two tests they will lose a point and trail the Proteas with 11. One victory to none will cost England two points. A drawn series will cost England 4 points.

Dunedin again rung the alarm bells for the lack of consistency and depth in the English batting line-up and it again showed how heavily they rely on Cook to score even more runs. When Cook was, for once, removed cheaply in the first innings, England managed only a very modest total.

In India, England found at least one capable partner for Cook in most games but the moment that changes, England has heaps of trouble with out of form batters.

Nick Compton might have sealed his place with a gritty maiden test ton; however, the Joe Root fan club, or shall I say Yorkshireman groupie, led by “Yorkshire” Boycs (Geoffrey Boycott), probably still believe he is better than the South African born opener.

A lot of hype was built around Root as the newest and freshest kid on the cricketing block, but in Dunedin he did his best to embarrass his godly status and hysteric followers. That said, it was clear that Ian Bell, and only “Marshmallow Brain” Bell, was to blame for the senseless run out of Root in England’s second innings.

The English will not listen to this and they will come in scores to prove me wrong but Root is overrated and not the saviour of England’s cricketing pride. He might play a role; but he is not the face of England’s cricketing future. That face might belong to James Taylor or Jonny Bairstow. For one or other unknown reason Taylor is not making the ECC cut at the moment.

Despite reasonable showings in Dunedin, Jonathan Trott and Bell’s careers continues on a downwards spiral. None of them can be counted on to win England tests and series. From an impossibly good start to test cricket Trott has been sussed out by opposing bowlers and his career average that were sky high disintegrated to below 50. Trott is looking more and more like the limited player we knew in South Africa.

Ian Bell finds himself in the same predicament and his average declined from 50 or more to 46.7. Bell was always erratic but before Nagpur in India he had a run of 24 innings without scoring a hundred.

KP Pietersen is another batter who dropped out of the 50-club and currently he averages just over 48.

England’s current bowling attack is seriously inadequate and Dunedin illustrated why the selectors are not convinced about Finn. He batted fine yes and probably rescued the test but he is in the team for his bowling, and that was appalling. Add to that Broad’s heal injury and the limitations of Tim Bresnan and Graham Onions and England must hope and pray that nothing bad happens to James Anderson.

Yes one can say in England’s defence that Swann was missing; and one can blame complacency, a lack of preparation, global warming and Stuart Broad’s misaligned chakras; but closer to the truth is the fact that the Kiwis was simply the best team on the field.

After being humiliated in South Africa the Kiwis, known for their grit and determination, turned up with a new attitude and a better team. Hamish Rutherford and Ross Taylor, who still looks a bit uneasy in the team context, were not in South Africa and it showed. The same applies to Bruce Martin, who made a good debut. Brendon McCullum, released of the opening bat, looked positive, relaxed and in control.

All in all Dunedin showed a lot for the Kiwis to build on and a lot for England to work on. It proved that this is not the dead rubber series England hoped for.

More still, England should cut down on their expectations for a white wash or even a victory in the first Ashes series.

Proteas firmly in control after brilliant test season

So then, the last test of the season is something of the past and Graeme Smith and his lads elevated the 2012/2013 season to the best in the history of South African cricket.

Second consecutive series victories in England and Australia in the same year cemented a new found confidence in the Protea squad and this time they embraced and clung to the status of being the best test team in the world.

The Proteas will now enter a cluster of ODI’s, including 5 against Pakistan and the ICC Champions Trophy in June.

The next test season starts with the Proteas touring Pakistan in October. Thereafter awaits the Indian tour of South Africa at the end of the year followed by a visit of the Ausies in February 2014.

The South Africans last lost a test in December 2011 against Sri Lanka and since they remained unbeaten. In 15 tests the Proteas won 10 and drew 5; 1 against England, 2 against the Kiwis and 2 against Australia. They won their last 6 tests: 1 versus Australia, 2 versus the Kiwis and 3 versus the Pakistanis.

The last test between the Proteas and Pakistan was certainly not dead rubber. To the contrary, on the official rankings it meant two additional points. If the Proteas drew the last test they would have accumulated two ranking points. If they lost and the series ended 2 – 1, they would have earned one point. Whitewashing the Pakistanis meant four points.

South Africa now leads England with an impressive 10 points on the ICC rankings table.

From now on the Britons will have to play catch-up cricket to overhaul the Proteas as the number one test team in the world.

As things stand at the moment the Proteas look set to dominate cricket for a long time.

In the 80’s and 90’s the Windies and after them the Australians had three qualities that elevated them to the leading test teams in the world. They won games they controlled. With moments of brilliance they won games that they were seemingly losing. When gutting it out in the middle was the only way to rescue games they did so.

Over the last 18 months the Proteas developed and displayed the same abilities and therefore it is not surprising that they are the best test team in the world.

Since readmission team spirit and unparalleled grit and determination made the Proteas a tough team to beat. For eighteen years they were better known for their doggish resistance that individual brilliance.

Over the last three years it all changed and currently most of the South African lads are either the best or in the top 10 of the ICC player’s rankings: Hashim Amla (1), AB de Villiers (4), Jacques Kallis (8), Dale Steyn (1), Vernon Philander (2) and Morne Morkel (9).

Still there is more. Graeme Smith is probably one of the best captains ever and certainly the most successful South African captain of all times. AB is the best batter/wicket keeper in the world and Kallis the best all-rounder around.

Some would regard it as fictitious but the Proteas can be better if some of the talent, lurking outside, are included in the team. Rilee Rossouw is a brilliant batter, the obvious successor for Kallis and a potential batting genius. Technically he is on par with AB and better than FAF du Plessis and Dean Elgar. It remains a mystery why he is not in the mix.

Quinton de Kock is a brilliant keeper and even a better batter. If the national side does not need his keeping abilities he should be there for his batting. However with AB not really into the glove work Quinton’s presence should be a formality.

Alviro Petersen is a good opener but not fulfilling his potential. If this trend continues Dean Elgar should get a go as Smith’s opening mate.

And then there is JP Duminy; and Johan Botha, who for some mystifying reason cannot convince the selection panel that he is South Africa’s best spinner in all formats of the game. Robin Peterson is not the solution for our spinner woes and Johan should take his place.

This team compares with the best of the Windies and Ausies when they were on song: Smith, Alviro/Dean, Hashim, Kallis, AB, Rossouw, De Kock, Botha, Philander, Steyn and Morkel.

Add JP Duminy, Dean, FAF, Robin, Marchant de Lange and Rory Kleinveldt and any change due to injury will be a seamless affair.